
Previous instalments dealt with trends and changes in jazz during the post-war period: ‘Bebob’, the flight into virtuosity that didn’t catch on much with audiences. ‘Cool jazz’ that took the hard edges off bebop. ‘Fusion’ and ‘smooth jazz’ that inspired musicians to mix jazz and other genres. ‘Free jazz’ that gave musicians room to break free from most of the rules that had hitherto governed jazz music and improvisation.
Several jazz musicians feel drawn to none of these trend and continue to search for the ‘true nature’ of jazz. It is obvious that not everyone thought the same way. The result is a range of new styles’, some of which this posts highlights. These include ‘hard bob’, ‘straight ahead jazz’ and ‘neo-bop’. ‘Soul jazz’ is often included in this list, but in my opinion, it belongs under ‘fusion’ and is also discussed there.
Hard bop (1950s – 1960s)
What distinguishes hard bop from bebop and cool jazz? Essentially, the difference is about increasing the appeal of jazz to a wider audience while preserving jazz as an art form.
Features
– As in bebop, solos take chord sequences as a starting point, which are repeated throughout the song.
– The tempo of hard bop is often as fast as that of bebop;
– The melodies are more recognizable and simpler.
– Piano and saxophone are dominant instruments.
Innovator Miles Davis introduced hard bob at the first Newport jazz festival (1954) with his song ‘Walking’. You can see and listen to this song on a 1957 recording here.
Other Miles Davis compositions from this era can be found on albums like ‘Milestones’ (1958) and ‘Kind of blue'(1959). You can now see and listen to the song ‘All Blues’ from this last album, played by the Frankfurt Radio Bigband (2020)
Other prominent hard bop musicians include Horace Silver and drummer Art Blakey with their band The jazz Messengers (Live in Belgium, 1958), trumpeter Clifford Brown (Stompin’at the Savoy, 1954), bassist Charles Mingus (Devil’s blues, a 1975 recording), saxophonist Cannonball Adderley (Work song, 1962), pianist Thelonious Monk (Live in 66 Norway & Denmark concerts, 1966) and flugelhorn player Lee Morgan (Moanin‘, 1961).
Straight ahead jazz and neo-bop (1980s and later)
Trumpeter Wynton Marsalis (1961 – ) played an important role in the succession of hard bop by ‘straight ahead jazz’ (1960s-70s) and neo-bop (from 1980s onwards). Marsalis’ ideal was also that jazz would achieve ‘fine-art’ status and would eventually be compared to classical music.
Features
– Both straight ahead jazz and neo-bob seek connection with old-time jazz and swing.
– Straight ahead jazz musicians reject both free jazz and fusion because of the influence of pop music.
– The emphasis is on acoustic instrumentation, such as conventional piano, walking bass patterns, 4/4 beat and swing and bop-based drum rhythms.
– Neo-bop had a more swinging and melodic character than straight ahead jazz, influenced by the styles that had developed in the pre-1980 period.
– ‘True’ jazz, according to Marsalis, was based on swing, acoustic sounds, tonality, craftsmanship and knowledge of the jazz tradition.
Wynton Marselis has performed in 30 countries. His Grammy Awards in jazz include for ‘Best Instrumental Solo’ : Think of one1(983) and Hot House Flowers, (1984) Best Jazz Instrumental Album : Black Codes (From The Underground) (1985, recorded 2013) and Marsalis Standard time (1987). You can listen to ‘Smokehouse Blues played by the Wynton Marsalis Septet in 2015 here.
Horace Silver and Art Blakey’s Jazz Messengers were also a breeding ground in terms of style for young musicians who wanted to play ‘true’ jazz. Marsalis, incidentally, also played in this group as a trumpeter. A leading album by the Jazz Messengers is ‘Straight Ahead ‘(1981). You can listen to ‘Just By Myself'(1958) here
Another ‘straightforward’ musician was tenor saxophonist Scott Hamilton. His first album was ‘Scott Hamilton Is A Good Wind Who is Blowing Us No Ill’(1977). Also: Jackie McLean with his album The Jackie Mac Attack live (1991) and Eric Alexander Solid (1998) , The second Milestone (2001) and Gentle Ballads (2008).
Several musicians who had made a mark on ‘fusion’ in the 1970s started recording acoustic jazz again, including Chick Corea and Herbie Hancock. Even Miles Davis’ music of the 1980s, though certainly still fusion, became more accessible and recognizable at that time than his abstract work of the mid-1970s. Nevertheless, he had nothing to do with neo-traditionalism. He spoke of a ‘warmed-up’ turkey and considered Marsalis the jazz police.
Coda
If you listen to bebop, cool jazz, hard bop, straight ahead jazz and neo-bop, you will hear a wide variety even within these styles and recognizing them is often difficult. Probably they represent the core of jazz. However, it is going too far to speak of ‘true jazz’. Fusion and free jazz have stretched the playing field and ultimately enriched jazz.




